Why Our Scoring Looks Nothing Like Your Current Leagues

We set out to create a new fantasy football experience resembling the ever-changing dynamics of an actual NFL Franchise General Manager (GM). We created Front Office Pros with this in mind; our scoring and roster settings have the following goals:

Defense finally matters. Full IDP means half your roster is real players making real plays on gameday, not a team DST you swap out every week based on the matchup.

Scoring mirrors the NFL. We built it so a top edge rusher carries close to the same weight as a top receiver. Micah Parsons and Justin Jefferson should both be franchise cornerstones. In FOP leagues, they are.

One QB, done right. No superflex gimmick. We rebuilt quarterback scoring from the ground up so the best QBs are your single most valuable asset.

If that sounds unorthodox, it is, on purpose. Here is why we made each decision.

To see all scoring settings, check out the Full Roster and Scoring Settings article.

Full IDP: the other half of football

Many leagues feature a single IDP slot where you can start any defensive position. This creates an abundance of options for this IDP spot. An abundance, or lack of scarcity, will drive value down, making this IDP spot an afterthought during your draft and roster decisions. FOP features a full 11-man defense modeled on an NFL starting unit. This creates the following dynamics:

IDP also takes more skill than a team DST. Instead of streaming a defense and inheriting whatever points it happens to produce, you are picking the actual player who makes the play. You will find yourself watching both sides of the ball, and gameday gets a lot more fun.

One note on positions: edge rushers are defensive ends in our format, not off-ball linebackers. TJ Watt and Myles Garrett are not linebackers in any way that matters for fantasy. Interior linemen are designated as defensive tackles for the same reason.

IDP was never fully accepted because there was no standard for IDP scoring, resulting in great difficulty aligning defense value with offense value. Our solution allows for ease of real-time tracking time while concurrently rewarding the premium positions (i.e., the defensive line).

In standard IDP, linebackers are the top scorers, which is 180 degrees out from the NFL where off-ball linebackers are the lowest-paid group on defense. FOP scores every category (linebackers, defensive backs, etc.) the same across positions except solo and assisted tackles. Tackles are the core stat every defender racks up. FOP tunes these two values to steer value toward the positions the league pays. A defensive tackle earns 2.5 points for a solo tackle while a linebacker earns 1.25, exactly double, which pulls interior linemen up toward their real NFL worth, precluding linebackers from running away with the scoring the way they do in standard IDP formats. The FOP scoring schema rewards a defensive end like Micah Parsons similarly to a receiver like Justin Jefferson, which is a far more accurate picture of NFL value.

The one position we cannot fully capture is cornerback. Shutdown corners like Patrick Surtain II win awards precisely because quarterbacks avoid them, which means they do not show up in the box score. One day we hope to fold in Next Gen Stats like yards and touchdowns allowed to give them their due.

See the value over replacement for a 12-team league in 2025 below. DEs and DTs are among the most valuable players. It is not uncommon to see a DE taken in the first few picks of a rookie draft.

Value Over Replacement — 12-Team League, 2025

PlayerRankPosTeamVOR
Myles Garrett1DECLE14.8
Puka Nacua2WRLA14.3
Jeffery Simmons3DTTEN14.0
Christian McCaffrey4RBSF13.6
Jaxon Smith-Njigba5WRSEA11.3
Jonathan Taylor6RBIND11.0
Trey McBride7TEARI10.8
Bijan Robinson8RBATL10.4
Matthew Stafford9QBLA10.0
Brian Burns10DENYG10.0
Ja'Marr Chase11WRCIN9.7
Jahmyr Gibbs12RBDET9.5
Drake Maye13QBNE9.5

One QB, rebuilt

The recent trend is superflex, and it does create QB value, but mostly by inflating middling quarterbacks. We kept it realistic with one starting QB, then rewrote the scoring so that quarterback is still one of the most important positions on your roster.

Traditional QB scoring is flawed. QBs are usually an afterthought in the draft because you can wait on them, and the only ones taken early are rushing QBs, who cash in with extra rushing yards and two more points for a rushing TD than a passing TD. A yard is a yard and a touchdown is a touchdown. Our scoring lets the best quarterbacks be the best quarterbacks, whether that is a dual threat like Lamar Jackson or a pocket passer like Joe Burrow. Start an NFL franchise today and Mahomes, Allen, Jackson, or Burrow are coveted cornerstones: a mix of both styles. Fantasy should be no different.

FOP’s scoring system is built on the same principle behind EPA (Expected Points Added), which is the percentage chance of scoring on a given drive. Positive plays like first downs earn points, and negative plays cost them. The TD to INT ratio is the most pivotal thing a QB controls, so interceptions, fumbles lost, and pick-sixes carry serious weight.

PFF's Eric Eager and George Chahrouri put numbers to it in 2018: from 2014 to 2017, touchdowns added an average of 3.74 EPA to an offense, while interceptions cost an average of 4.65 EPA over the same stretch. Turnovers do not just fail to score, they actively bury a drive.

Sacks are a QB stat too. Analyst Ben Baldwin has shown that variation in team sack rates is driven primarily by quarterbacks, not offensive lines. In Russell Wilson's last year in Denver he took 45 sacks in 15 games. Behind the same core line the next season, Bo Nix took 24. Quarterbacks evade the rush, audible, slide protections, and throw the ball away. That is on them, so we score it that way.

With FOP, penalties for negative plays are deliberately costlier due to the sever negative impacts. An interception costs 10 points, a lost fumble costs 8, and a skill player still drops a point on a fumble his own team recovers. As the numbers above show, a giveaway does not just waste a possession, it hands one to the other side. The result is negative impact of putting the ball on the ground hurts more, like in the NFL.

Two additional stats: every pass attempt is worth minus 1, and every completion is worth plus 1.5. This combination turns completion percentage into a scoring category. A quarterback who throws an efficient, accurate game climbs, while one who forces low-percentage throws will lose you points. It is the same signal NFL front offices use to separate the top QBs.

The result of these stat changes: the top QBs in FOP scoring are roughly 2x more valuable than a top QB in a standard PPR league, based on value over replacement for the same 12-team league in 2025.

12-Team FOP Scoring

PlayerTeamVOR
Matthew StaffordLA10.0
Drake MayeNE9.5
Josh AllenBUF6.4
Dak PrescottDAL6.2
Brock PurdySF5.7
Jared GoffDET4.6
Patrick MahomesKC3.3
Daniel JonesIND0.8
Bo NixDEN0.7
Caleb WilliamsCHI0.3

12-Team PPR Scoring

PlayerTeamVOR
Josh AllenBUF5.3
Drake MayeNE3.2
Matthew StaffordLA3.1
Patrick MahomesKC2.9
Trevor LawrenceJAX2.4
Brock PurdySF2.2
Jalen HurtsPHI1.4
Caleb WilliamsCHI1.3
Dak PrescottDAL1.0
Bo NixDEN0.5

Tiered PPR

FOP provides a few enhancements to the more traditional PPR scoring: receptions are worth 0.5 for a RB, 1 for a WR, and 1.5 for a TE.

Running backs are already guaranteed touches on the ground, so half-point PPR keeps dual-threat backs from overshadowing elite pure runners like Derrick Henry. Wide receivers at a full point is standard, and we saw no reason to change it. Tight ends at 1.5 is TE premium scoring, which makes elite tight ends genuinely coveted instead of an afterthought and opens up more ways to build a roster.

Skill players also lose a point on any fumble, even if the offense recovers it. Putting the ball on the ground is a negative play regardless of who falls on it. And like QBs, they earn a point for rushing and receiving first downs, because a first down keeps the chains moving.

Special teams

With no team DST, special-teams production goes to the individual players who earn it.

Kick return yards are worth 1 per 25 on purpose. Under the new kickoff rules, kick returners can easily pick up 25 yards per kickoff. A returner should not out-earn the 25 yards their team would get by simply kneeling in the landing zone, so we priced it accordingly. Punt return yards are 1 per 10, because punt returners can be tackled the instant they catch it and that yardage is genuinely harder to come by.

Yes, it is unorthodox. It is also the closest fantasy scoring gets to real NFL value.